You sure know how to throw a monkey wrench into the mix ;-).
My gut tells me that over time JSR-170 will be more and more a absolute requirement. That is, the argument for JSR-170 JCR would be made more on non-technical/social merits than technical ones.
In summary, I liked your product when it came out; unfortunately, as much as I hate to say this, sometimes standardization has its merits. The way I look at it, Roy Fielding of ReST fame is Chief Scientist as Day, the primary developer of JCR. So, therefore, despite not having looked deeply into it myself, I'm fairly confident that the specification (unlike EJB) is fundementally sound.
You sure know how to throw a monkey wrench into the mix ;-).
My gut tells me that over time JSR-170 will be more and more a absolute requirement. That is, the argument for JSR-170 JCR would be made more on non-technical/social merits than technical ones.
In summary, I liked your product when it came out; unfortunately, as much as I hate to say this, sometimes standardization has its merits. The way I look at it, Roy Fielding of ReST fame is Chief Scientist as Day, the primary developer of JCR. So, therefore, despite not having looked deeply into it myself, I'm fairly confident that the specification (unlike EJB) is fundementally sound.
Carlos